Extra Space Storage - 1192 - Middletown - Pameacha Av

Rafael Pimenta

Had a nice experience. The employee was polite and answer all my questions. Would recommend to anyone looking for storage.

R T

February 17, 2026

2nd UPDATE : went back and negotiated room and price and got a much better deal and better location...... UPDATE : I was just notified that my bill will be doubled and that my original rate 3 months ago for $70 a month will now be $142 for a 10 foot by 5 foot space, kind of ridiculous.I put a call in and we will see where this goes. So from $70 a month to $142 for a 10 foot by 5 foot space ??? !!!!!! Seriously.... !!!! This previous review following might be changing VERY SOON. --------- I’ve had a great experience with Extra Space Storage in Middletown, CT. The facility is exceptionally clean and very easy to access, which makes every visit quick and stress-free. One of the things I appreciate most is the strong sense of safety—having an attendant on site during working hours gives me real peace of mind and confidence that any issue would be handled promptly. The property is well maintained, well lit, and feels secure at all times. Parking is also abundant and conveniently laid out, making loading and unloading easy. Overall, this location has exceeded my expectations, and I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend it to anyone looking for a reliable and safe storage facility.

Trons Jonder

December 30, 2025

I just moved here and needed a place to put some things. Signed up online only to get a card at my new address about 4 weeks later that my rate increased about 60 percent, the even charged me for a lock I didn’t need and other charges. My web rate was about 60 for this very small area and on the card it said 110 or so as my new rate, the ultimate bait and switch. That’s classes. Also I noticed people living in the units.

Jesus Manuel Cruz

Good size storage ask if they are having promos to save $$$

Mark Grano

January 6, 2026

Beware, 30 days after your first payment they will double your rate. You’ll also see mice running around. Waiting to see how they respond to my email before I start publishing photos of all vacant units and conditions inside this facility. Their claim of market conditions is not valid. Extra Space Storage – Middletown / Nearby • 5×5 units: as low as ~$39–$60/mo nationally listed around Middletown area listings.  • 10×10 units near Middletown reported around ~$64/mo online special.  • Middletown area prices reported in broader local listings as low as $44/mo up to ~$382 depending on size.  Other Middletown Area Self-Storage (Competitors) • Top Value Storage CT — 10×5 units ~$80–$95/mo • CT Self Stor — 10×10 units as low as $86+/mo Third-Party Averages • Across Middletown storage listings: • 5×5 ~ $39/mo • 5×10 ~ $61–$97/mo • 10×10 ~ $64–$120/mo These aren’t just Extra Space quotes — they reflect multiple local facilities within the region.